28 Comments

It all comes down to this: Substack it's still in it's honeymoon period.

Now it's the time to invest in it. No one know how long it will last.

Expand full comment

Exactly!

Just subscribed to your newsletter and look forward to reading your longer posts after having read lots of your notes.

Expand full comment

Wow! I'm honored to have a Substack bestseller among my subscribers.

I'll try my best to reciprocate, though I'm in the discovery phase and I'm subscribed to too many publications. 😨

Expand full comment

Out of curiosity, what is the publication you read the most consistently?

Expand full comment

Now it's a mess. I stopped email notifications because I'm subscribing to something every day, to reciprocate and to "spy" the competition 😉

Before, I read

Todd Brain

Alex Mathers

Noah Smith

The exponential view

Other newsletters outside Substack.

Expand full comment

Yea, I have a whole folder called Substack newsletters that I point everything to at the moment too.

I think many people are in some phase of the following process:

1. Discovery phase: exploring what to read and subscribing to lots of stuff.

2. Digesting phase: Realizing that time is too limited to read everything and that some newsletters are more consistently read and valuable than others.

3. Pruning phase: Unsubscribing to lots of emails.

My hypothesis is that a lot of the gains will go to the newsletters that are in people's top 3-5 newsletters and a lot of other newsletters will be unsubscribed from.

Expand full comment

I have a different approach. I didn’t want to miss everything an author published.

So, I’m treating my newsletter folder almost like a feed: I am very selective about what I open and read.

I quickly archive emails if they seem not interesting. I unsubscribe if I sense that I’ve been “skipping” too many emails from the same author.

Expand full comment

Substack is a hidden gem

Expand full comment

I really like the purpose of the platform, the general purpose of the newsletter and in my opinion you have summarized the characteristic aspects of the platform excellently, almost as if it were a real manifesto. The most important point in my opinion is that of the community, in addition to the interactions and comments regarding the various neslwetters, one perceives an active, real exchange of concrete interactions on what is published and written. Thanks for making it clear in this post!

Expand full comment

Thanks Riccardo!

Expand full comment

Michael, we're really doing this! It's always cool to hear your story going from Medium to Substack and hearing about all you learned. I can't wait to kick off this challenge with you.

Expand full comment

Thanks Michael and Tom for everything you are doing! I've needed a place to just commit to writing Notes and understand how to get the ball rolling. Thank you!

Expand full comment

Congratulations 😊. Only 1 thing to add: no possible to export followers, only subscribers

Expand full comment

Good point. Email is based on SMTP open protocol. Podcast feature is based on RSS. But Substack Noted is not based on an open protocol like activity Pub.

Expand full comment

Thanks Michael and thanks Tom! I had subscribed and quickly upgraded to you both separately as a new user to the platform which is testament to the quality of your writing respectively. So looking forward to your combined brilliance in the upcoming Substack Campfire.

Expand full comment

Thanks Rob! Looking forward to getting to know you better and collaborating though this newsletter and Substack Campfire!

Expand full comment

Great idea, guys. Sounds like a fun challenge, and I’m looking forward to the master class!

Expand full comment

Thanks Ken!

Expand full comment

Nice! Except the part about medium changing its algorithm.

Expand full comment

'To succeed online, you also need to align with the right platforms for you and strike while the iron is hot.'

True, unfortunately. As content creators, we gotta consistently be aware of the changes in the platforms, decide which ones are more relevant to us, and whether or not we should stick to our current ones or shift to new ones.

The landscape changes unfortunately over time.

Expand full comment

this is amazing, thanks for sharing your journey and reasoning behind it. looks like you made the right choice ;)

Expand full comment

How important do you think it was that you already had such a large following? I had no list when Tom invited me to join him in teh transition form Medium to Substack and afer an initial growth spurt I appear to have plateaued.

I keep reading from others who have seen amazing growth that they had a significant following they imported or invited and then had them help them grow with recommendations, et.c

I have also been wondering if writing about writing and self help, personal development is currently more attractive to the substack community than my work in business and finance?

Expand full comment

Good questions.

I do think that everything we bring (fans, skills, knowledge, brand, CV) can help us transition faster.

Getting in at the right platform at the right time is a boost, but it is not a panacea.

I don’t know your personal situation and its nuances, so I don’t have specific advice, but my broad, longterm advice is that consistency and improvement are all that matter longterm. And my advice with Substack would be to learn from others who have figured it out by paying for consulting (I recently paid for consulting from Sarah Fay), signing up for relevant courses/Substacks, building relationships, analysing top people’s content for patterns, and doing a ton of experimentation.

Hope that helps.

Expand full comment

Thans Michael

I agree and I am doing the same and will participate in Campfire. I am also connected to Sarah but haven't been participating in one of her cohorts

Expand full comment

Can't wait for this and to have you two as guides to get moving on here.

PS: Does Tom have a man-bun again?

Expand full comment

Why I'm all in on this is its still your list... the algo's will change over time, but the ability to collaborate with other creators, have a central place for all types of content (not sending people to YouTube to be distracted away, etc.) makes this a platform that could be the dominate place for educational and entertainment for the next several years or decade.... come on Substack I'm rooting for you... don't mess it up. LOL

Expand full comment

Im confused. Is blockbuster.thoughtleader.school substack or is it something different?

Expand full comment

Good question, and I didn’t even realize this could be confusing but now I get it. Blockbuster.thoughtleader.school is hosted on Substack.

Expand full comment